Second Draft

An investigation into how the representation in the media of religious fundamentalism impacts on contemporary society.

"rejection of the network may motivate Al-Qaida terrorism, which may therefore be said to be a product of its extension across the world"

Religious fundamentalism is bad enough, causing death and havoc around the world as it is but could the media be sensationalising these ideological extremists through their coverage and directly affecting society? This essay intends to explore the representations of religious fundamentalism in both contemporary and historical texts and compare what has changed over time and the factors that could have influenced them, for example. There appears to be attention towards fundamentalism so that, for influence, "Anjem Choudhary remains a constantly invited figure, even on the BBC, because he offers them entertainment. People are being sucked into a game of sensationalism" , but it would appear that audiences are willing, active participants. Another key area being explored will be the media effects on society through the way it controls audiences.

The stereotypes the media creates of religious fundamentalists impacts upon society and then they becomes normalised to everyone. An example of these stereotypes would be how a bearded Asian man carrying a large rucksack would now posts 9/11 straight away induce anxiety. These are stereotypes that have been reinforced by the media by repeatedly showing images of so called fundamentalists with a Middle Eastern look. In texts such as The Kingdom the religious fundamentalists all seem to be heavily bearded and seem to be excessively serious about their religion. A prime example of this in recent times is the mockeries of Abu Hamza a well known terrorist and the sun placed on their front page a picture of Abu Hamza showing his hook hand and the headline “Hook and the hooker” . After doing this the Sun was able to scapegoat the demonic figure of Abu Hamza for the entire Islamic world. The film is a prime example of how the media links fundamentalism back to certain religions, in particular Islam. With this link created it inevitably generates a negative attitude towards the religion and people who like a Muslim creates Islam phobia within society. "Just as “Rambo” offered the fantasy of do-over on Vietnam, “The Kingdom” can be seen as a wishful revisionist scenario for the American response to Islamic fundamentalist terrorism."

However the representation of fundamentalist and terrorists has not always related to religious beliefs. A good example of this is shown in the 1970’s film Airport where the text is based around a plane being hijacked by a fundamentalist. The fundamentalist in this film however is shown to be an everyday white American. This when compared to films from the modern age such as The Kingdom we can see that in the modern age films represent the fundamentalists with religion and of an eastern background. This also shows how the media has changed along with society's view and how we now view Muslims as the “other”. Post 9/11 the view of fundamentalism along with religion was scarce in the media. The media media's views moving with society about people can be summed up in this quote “The way in which individuals actions are determined is by social class, economic position and ideologies of gender or race" . The the media determines individual’s actions through ideologies of gender and race and in this case this would be their representation of the fundamentalists.

The way the media represents "terrorists" has a direct impact on society itself. Print media has just as much to do with this than TV and films does. Newspapers favouring the Conservative party seem to be against "terrorists" and like to link Islam directly with terrorism to get their views across to the public. A recent article in the Telegraph read [4]"Dozens of Islamic terrorists in Britain released from prison" . This is how newspapers create this image of Islam to be associated with terrorism before the reader has even begun to read the full article. With these headlines the newspapers sensationalise the stories and in this case try and create moral panics in society. The words dozens, Islamic, terrorists and released when read in a readers mind instantly creates a moral panic as it makes them feel as though these Islamic terrorist are free and a threat to them. “Many believe the term was coined by Stanley Cohen to describe press reporting and the reaction of the establishment to the behaviour of mods and rockers” . Stanley Cohen brought moral panics to the forefront and in this present day is used by the news industries to manipulate audiences. Audiences use the news as a way of surveillance if we relate this back to uses and gratification theory; this goes to show how important it is to people and why it really impacts them. A quote that also shows how this works is [5] "the public's views are further manipulated by tabloid headlines" . This backs up the view that newspapers manipulate the public's view with their headlines. However, “one of the categories that Galtung and Ruge suggested for news values was negativity – the idea that bad news is good news. ” With all the moral panics being created it has a huge impact on society as most the population become victims of this manipulation and this Islam phobia being generated. This then leads to attacks on Muslims and protest against them in the U.K. By these coming about more negative stereotypes have been created against Muslims and the most obvious one would be all Muslims are "terrorists". This is a view some of society is taking on board from what representations they are receiving in the media.

The radio is another platform where I can't help but find the media exaggerating and doing nothing more than just promoting fundamentalism. "In Our Time Fundamentalism" is a BBC 4 radio show that talks about fundamentalism itself and the believers in it. This would also mean the message of fundamentalism and why it is done can be heard through the radio and potentially go out to thousands of listeners around the U.K. This in itself to some people could be promoting fundamentalism although be it in a mediated form it is still promoting. Although there are radio shows fighting another side of this argument in saying "Is al-Qaeda winning?” This was form a news quiz show on BBC radio four and discussed the issue or the fundamentalists winning because of all this media attention they receive. The media might not represent them in a positive way but the message the fundamentalists are trying to make gets across most the time on a global scale. At least the radio does not stereotype people and mark fundamentalism down with certain religions when touching the issues. This is a positive sign in the media where religion is not being brought down with it so stereotypes are not being created in society but there is still the issue of promoting the work of fundamentalists that the radio does.

The internet is the biggest source of media on the planet so it would only make sense for the media industry to command a lot of influence of users and consumers over the net every day. All the media’s biggest companies also have their own source of media through the web so it would not be hard to assume that these values discussed earlier from the movies will carry over to the internet. The net is also filled with the media created moral panics such as “Terrorist threat level raised to 'severe” to try and grab people attention. This does nothing more than created moral panics between internet users everyday through the words terrorist threat raised to severe, the media in this case The Times online is scaring readers into thinking the threat is worse than first thought. The media is so powerful and on the net can even try and turn continents towards their beliefs in this case The Times online. “Stoned to death... why Europe is starting to lose its faith in Islam” is an article written by The Times online trying to get the message across that religious fundamentalism is the reason why the western world is losing faith in Islam. The truth is that Islam itself has nothing to do with fundamentalism and this is all stereotyping and representations created by the media to influence consumers. The Times Online seems to think “Islamic fundamentalism is causing a 'clash of civilisations' between liberal democracies and Muslims” which shows exactly the intentions of this article and there take on fundamentalism. In the present media “Islam is seen as an "extremist", "terrorist", or "fundamental" religion” which might explain why Media companies such as The Times Online might make such representations but it is they themselves who create these representations and then relate it to religion in this case Islam. When realistically addressing the issue with an open mind it comes across as "A complex issue like western attitudes to Islamic fundamentalism cannot be adequately represented within the confines of a news story" as it does not portray the truth to consumers. The times newspapers are known to supporter the conservative party who are not very fond of immigration into the U.K. as most eastern European countries are Islamic it shows why The Times would write negative comments for their political affiliation.
A recent article on the Guardian online webpage talked about “The world's most influential Muslims?” Which looked into the top 500 Muslim figures in the world? The fact that they put Osama Bin Laden in second place just shows how much influence they think fundamentalism has over Islam across the world. The fact is “Bin Laden is on the list – as a radical. Funny, I thought he was a terrorist” which really comes Bin Laden second on the top 500 most influential Muslims in the world it is directly linking terrorism with Islam to the consumers of media. This creates a positive representation of a terrorist that should be locked up in jail and instead is glorified as the second most influential Muslims in the world.
A huge phenomenon in recent times on the internet is social networking with sites such as Twitter and Facebook. These now also controlled by media giants and have created this representation of “choosing or being forced to live outside the network is associated with fundamentalism" to obviously make people stay inside the network for their own benefits. This could influence society to chose to stay inside the network when online and in fact manipulate them to a certain extend all through representations given out by the media companies themselves. Looking into the deeper meaning of media texts put out to audiences a certain Ferdinand de Saussure’s semiotics theory comes to mind. His theory looked into signs and symbols and what they could mean in media texts and how different audiences would receive them. Looking at the film The Hurt Locker there’s a scene where the American protagonist is defusing a bomb in the middle of a street in Iraq. Now a couple of eastern bystanders start to gather to watch this and all camera angles switch from our main characters to the bystanders. Now to the passive audience this could connote danger and maybe these people left the bomb there, but to a more active audience this could connote innocent bystanders who came to see what all the commotion was about. The way that the passive audience would automatically relate and Middle Eastern person with an act of terrorism shows how the semiotics theory applies.
A more relative theory that comes across when looking at the media and its effects on society may be the information or representations it pumps into the audience’s heads. This now more relates to the hyperdermic syringe model. This theory looks into how the media use techniques to pump their views and in this case their representations into the passive audience’s minds. The Kingdom shows scenes of the terrorist reciting from what looks like the Quran which is the holy book of Islam and therefore pumping into the passive audience’s minds that the terrorists are related to Islam. This is an effective method mostly used by directors to get their views or the views of the institution behind the media product across to the audiences. This of course has its affects on society as with these representations being pumped into audiences it will create negative feelings towards Islam and Muslims in the contemporary society.
In my own views after embarking on my voyage of research and analysis of the media industry across many different media platforms there many issues I have come to terms with. The media has a huge amount of influence across all the media platforms and can get their own views across to a lot of passive audiences without the audiences even realising. For the most part the media industry does seem to relate Islam with terrorism and create a lot of representations and stereotypes out of this in texts. These representations and stereotypes carry over into society and a negative view of Islam is created and a lot of anger and hate is thrown towards Muslims in society. The times newspaper has shown an example of exactly how they can create moral panics in society and get people with this negative image of Islam. The times are a known supporter of the conservative party and could be the reason behind the shown negative comments about Islam. Overall I think the media do impact the society very deeply with all the representations as I cannot help but feel religion is the real victim in the end.
Word count: 2,321
Works cited
Books
1. Hartley,John.(2002): Communication, Culture and Media studies, USA, Routledge.
14. Bennet, Peter.Slater, Jerry.Wall, Peter. (2006): A2 media studies the essential introduction, USA, Routledge Page 173.
6. D, Buckingham (1987) Public Secrets Eastenders and its audience, London, Arnold p56.
17. Hartley, John. (2002): Communication, Culture and Media studies, USA, Routledge. p161.
8. Probert, David. Graham, Anderew. (2008): Advanced media studies, Oxfordshire, Philip Alan updates. Page 133.
9. Rayner, Philip Wall, Peter, Kruger, Stephen (2004): AS Media Studies: The Essential Introduction. London, Routledge.

Internet
1. Title: Sensationalism is a gift to extremists
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2009/aug/12/birmingham-riots-extremism-media.
3. Title: Abu Hamza al-Masri was a participant or observer in the following events:
http://www.historycommons.org/events-images/b138_abu_hamza_sun_2050081722-21846.jpg.

4 Title: MOVIE REVIEW The Kingdom (2007), http://movies.nytimes.com/2007/09/28/movies/28king.html.
7. Title: Dozens of Islamic terrorists in Britain released from prison
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/terrorism-in-the-uk/6160758/Dozens-of-Islamic-terrorists-in-Britain-released-from-prison.html.
10. Title: Cut the cosy stuff. I want rage
http://www.guardian.co.uk/culture/2008/oct/05/radio.bb

11. Title: Religious fundamentalism http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio4/programmes/subjects/c3ViamVjdC9yZWxpZ2lvdXMgZnVuZGFtZW50YWxpc20

12. Title:
Terrorist threat level raised to 'severe http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/uk/article6999294.ece
13. ibid
14. Title: Islam and the Western Media
http://www.islamfortoday.com/media.htm
15. Title: The world's most influential Muslims?
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/belief/2009/nov/19/500-influential-muslims-list

16. ibid
Moving Texts

18. Bigelow, K. (2008). USA: Summit Entertainment..
19. Berg, P. (2008).The Kingdom, USA: Universal Studios.
2. Berg, P. (2008).The Kingdom, USA: Universal Studios.
5. Seaton, G. (1974).Airport, USA: Good Times Video.
Radio
8. Bragg.M (2009) BBC 4 Radio 25/11/09
Works Consulted
Books:
Bignell,Jonathan.(2004): An introduction to television studies, USA, Routledge.
Casey,Bernadette.Casey,Neil.Calvert,Ben.French, Liam. Lewis, Justin.(2002) : television studies they key concepts, USA, Routledge.
Jewkes,Yvonne.O'sullivan, Tim.(1997): The media studies reader, London, Arnold..
Lauhney,Dan.(2009): Media studies theories and approches,Herts, Kamera books.
Williams,Kevin.(2003): Understanding media theory, London, Arnold.
Internet
:http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/commentators/johann-hari/renouncing-islamism-to-the-brink-and-back-again-1821215.html
An Islamic view from society who don't understand why Islamists are in Britain.

:http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-deports-yusuf-islam-over-claims-that-he-supports-terrorist-groups-547332.html
Could be used this quote to show how a Muslim feels towards the issue dealing with it in society.

Link: http://rogerebert.suntimes.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20050505/REVIEWS/50502001/1023


http://www.manaa.org/asian_stereotypes.html

Essay targets and plan

After the feedback recieved from my peers it was clear that I needed to go into more depth about any topics I touched. For example when I talked about a theory I should have flag posted it for the reader and made it clear I knew what I was talking about. Another issue was research as I discovered there were more topic and debates in the subject I could research into. Not only this but even more research to back up any points made already in the essay are also needed. when my peers highlighted my work there were a lot of issues and debates all over the essay but once again I need to focus on expanding on each point. The writing style was not too bad but still needs improving if i want a better grade. The bibliography was ok but I need to add the websites names into the internet section. Footnotes had minimal errors. In terms of theory I could have used a lot more audience theorys to go into depth about how this really affects consumers or media.

My next steps:

My first next step is to go through the peer to peer marking presentation and go through my essay and highlight and annotate everything to make sure i make all the needed to improve.

Next target is to get the needed research to cover a range of topics and to back up any points I do make in the essay.

My last target is to get atleast one grade above what I got this time and show myself I have made some decent progrression with the essay.

Update

Action plan:


Week 6 22nd March - 26th March - This week is the final week and we will finish off all our editing for a review from Mr Bush and get his advice on any way to improve it before submission this way we aim to secure top mark and produce a production of professional standards. we might have to work extra in our own time to fix any mistakes or anything gone wrong which is why we want to finish all editing at the tart of the week

Progress report:
Week 5 15th March - 19th March - This week we started our editing, this will affect where we work more. This was in school as we decieded to use premire. We we edited the video how we want and added our effects into it and at school and making a title sequence and credits to make it look professional.